Showing posts with label Historical Fiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Historical Fiction. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 25, 2010

The Secret Garden

It was incredibly difficult to pick just one favorite book this week. I read a whole bunch of amazing books this week. A View from Saturday (E. L. Konigsburg), Keys to the Demon Prison, Fablehaven 5 (Brandon Mull)the final book!, A Spy in the House, The Agency 1(Y. S. Lee), and lastly, The Red Pyramid, Kane Chronicles 1 (Rick Riordan). They were all awesome and any other week could have made my number one. 

Frances Hodgson Burnett. The Secret Garden
Sterling Publishing Company, Inc. (2004 ed.), 1911
Middle Grade, Historical Fiction, Classic

"When Mary Lennox was sent to Misselthwaite Mannor to live with her uncle everybody said she was the most disagreeable-looking child ever seen."

I never read this classic as a child but I did watch the movie, many times. I bought the book a few years ago, and I'm thrilled that I did. This story about two spoiled and unloved children learning to live and care about other people makes me want to go out in a field and frolic in the sunshine. I am not a gardener by any means, but a secret garden, a place to go where no one knows you are or how to find you. A place that is your own little hiding place. A place that is yours because you nurture it and help things to grow. A wild place in nature, to be alone, or with your very best friends exclusively. That kind of place is appealing to me.

This book is about people and a garden coming alive. Mary is a orphan who was neglected by her parents. Colin is a cripple who was neglected by his father. Both are spoiled and self-centered. But the garden gives them something to care about, a new idea for both of them. And their new friend Dickon is there to show them how, to introduce them to animals and the moorlands.

I also love Misselthwaite. A huge British house in the moorlands, with so many rooms to be explored. That sounds like a great time to me.

I love this book. The end.

Monday, May 3, 2010

Kilmeny of the Orchard [Lucy Maud Montgomery]


Lucy Maud Montgomery. Kilmeny of the Orchard
Random House Publishing, 1910.
Historical Fiction. YA.

The sunshine of a day in early spring, honey pale and honey sweet, was showering over the red brick buildings of Queenslea College and the grounds about them, throwing through the bare, budding maples and elms, delicate, evasive etchings of gold and brown on the paths, and coaxing into life the daffodils that were peering greenly and perkily up under the windows of the co-eds' dressing room.

Reaction
I loved this book when I was younger. I can't say the same thing now. It's a love story about a man who falls in love with a mute woman. I still like Kilmeny, she's innocent and good and strong. But Eric? How arrogant can one guy be? He's handsome and rich and all that good stuff, which is fine, but he KNOWS it. Eric acts like it's obvious that Kilmeny will love him and completely dismisses the jealousy of another guy. I love Montgomery's books but this is one that did not translate well to me from childhood to adulthood. I still enjoyed the plot line, it's simple and sweet, but the "hero" of the story was full of himself.

Thursday, March 5, 2009

Here Lies Arthur

Here Lies Arthur by Philip Reeves
2007. Scholastic Press. 333 pgs.


Teen: Arthurian

First line: Even the woods are burning.

Myrddrin takes Gwynna in after Arthur burns down her master’s home. Gwynna plays the lady of the lake and gives Arthur his sword. She is turned into a boy and lives with Myrddrin for the next few years. Gwynna's adventures as a young boy and then a young girl are chronicled. She alone knows all the different truths and secrets about people. A reimagining of Arthurian legends where the real Arthur is a brutish warlord and the Arthur of legend is only in the stories spun by Myrddrin.

I have mixed feelings about this book. There were many elements that I liked and many I disliked. As a rule, I’m a big fan of Arthurian literature. (although I have yet to read Morte d’Arthur- it’s on my list!) But parts of it, particularly at the beginning, were difficult to read and understand. Gwynna obviously struggles with her identity- is she a boy? Is she a girl? Which one does she want to be? Life is difficult for her as a girl. The boys don’t notice her because she isn’t pretty, but she’s unsure that she wants to be noticed because she knew how they really viewed girls, and it wasn’t polite!

Gwynna also struggles with abandonment and the belief that no one loves her, not even Myrddrin. He becomes indirectly responsible for sending her towards an assured death and his health rapidly declines.

The love story between Gwynna and Peredur was pathetically weak. I’m a girl who loves a little romance and there wasn’t any at all in this book. He ignores her for the entire book and then all of a sudden in two pages they are kissing and going away together.

The best part of the book was its exploration into the power of storytelling. There were no magical elements in this novel, only tricks and deception woven by a master storyteller.

Favorite Quotes:


"Gwenhwyfar wants only him. She’s chosen him. She watches him so intently when they are together. She takes him so seriously.
And isn’t’ that what all boys want and all men, too? Just to be taken seriously?"

Surrender Tree


The Surrender Tree: Poems of Cuba’s Struggle for Freedom by Margarita Engle
Children, Novel in Verse, Historical Fiction
2008, Newbery Honor 2009

First line: Some people call me a child-witch,
but I’m just a girl who likes to watch
the hands of the women
as they gather wild herbs and flowers to heal the sick

Rosa was a healer and a famous Cuban nurse during their wars for independence. She grew up a slave but was freed at the beginning of the book. She marries Jose, and they hide in the forests and built make-shift hospitals. She did not discriminate in those she healed and helped, even healing Lieutenant Death, whose job it was to hunt her down and turn her over to Spain. Their thoughts and feelings about the struggle for freedom are written in poems. Eventually a young escaped girl, Sylvia, makes her way into their care and learns the ways of a healer. The wars finally come to an end but Cuba still does not have the freedom it longs for, instead they are under the rule of the United States.

I am not usually a fan of poetry, but historical novels-in-verse are really growing on me. I appreciated their struggles more because it was poetry instead of prose. Their stories were harrowing and beautiful, their kindness undiminished in all the turbulence. The fact that it was the story of real people is cool but it made the betrayal of the Americans all the more harsh. I am disappointed in the role America played in Cuba’s history.

Favorite Quotes:

"Can it be true that freedom only exists
when it is a treasure,
shared by all?"

­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­
"Each choice leads to another.
I am a nurse.
I must heal the wounded.
How well the Lion knows me! Didn’t he say
that curing the enemies
is not my own skill, but a mercy from God?
Each choice leads to another.
I am a nurse.
I must heal."


"Are some deaths
smaller than others,
leaving mothers who weep a little less?
But all I see is death, always the same,
always enormous, never little."


"Young people drift on airy daydreams.
Old folks help hold them in place."


"Peace is not the paradise
I imagined, but it is a chance
to dream…"