Saturday, June 5, 2010
Enna Burning
Monday, May 3, 2010
Kilmeny of the Orchard [Lucy Maud Montgomery]

Lucy Maud Montgomery. Kilmeny of the Orchard
Random House Publishing, 1910.
Historical Fiction. YA.
The sunshine of a day in early spring, honey pale and honey sweet, was showering over the red brick buildings of Queenslea College and the grounds about them, throwing through the bare, budding maples and elms, delicate, evasive etchings of gold and brown on the paths, and coaxing into life the daffodils that were peering greenly and perkily up under the windows of the co-eds' dressing room.
Reaction
I loved this book when I was younger. I can't say the same thing now. It's a love story about a man who falls in love with a mute woman. I still like Kilmeny, she's innocent and good and strong. But Eric? How arrogant can one guy be? He's handsome and rich and all that good stuff, which is fine, but he KNOWS it. Eric acts like it's obvious that Kilmeny will love him and completely dismisses the jealousy of another guy. I love Montgomery's books but this is one that did not translate well to me from childhood to adulthood. I still enjoyed the plot line, it's simple and sweet, but the "hero" of the story was full of himself.
Monday, March 22, 2010
Charles and Emma [Deborah Heiligman]

Deborah Heiligman. Charles and Emma: The Darwins' Leap of Faith
Henry Holt and Company, 2009
YA, Biography, Printz
Summary
I love the cover of this book. The black silhouettes of are very appealing to me and perfect for a historical biography. The woman is holding a cross and an upright ape is behind the man. It illustrates perfectly what values each person holds.
This book is first and foremost a biography about Charles Darwin but it tells the story of his marriage to Emma. Their love and understanding of one another drove the biography forward because they were not of one mind on two very important issues, religion and science. Emma was a devoted to her faith and Charles’ beliefs caused her pain. But they challenged one another to think about science and life from different perspectives.
Charles Darwin was sickly all of his life, and the thought that he was not going to be able to go to heaven pained Emma a great deal. Her love for him was strong enough to remain loyal and true despite her misgivings about his afterlife. Charles always listened to Emma’s ideas and considered them carefully. Mutual respect for each other was a strong foundation in their marriage and the ability to rely on one another helped them through the hard times, including the deaths of some of their children and the publication of the theory of evolution.
Reaction
I enjoyed the give and take between Charles and Emma. As a person who has struggled with the issue of faith vs. science I can appreciate the arguments found in this novel. I also think that it treats each side with respect and that it is a good example for teenagers to be reading. Above all, Charles and Emma respected each other’s opinions. They shared, argued, debated and generally tried to convince each other that they were right and the other was wrong but were always able to come together in love afterwards. Charles and Emma knew how to debate without letting anger and fear drive them apart. It is an important example for young and old alike.
Sorcerers and Secretaries Vol. 1 [Amy Kim Ganter]

Amy Kim Ganter. Sorcerers and Secretaries [Vol. 1]
TokyoPop Inc., 2006
YA, Realistic Fiction, Graphic Novel
Summary
Nicole is unhappy with her life. She’s unhappy at school. She’s unhappy at work. Nicole is only happy when she is dreaming of and imagining her fantasy world. She records her stories about the sorcerer, Ellon, who must go on a quest to save his soul after his familiar betrays him, in her dream journal.
Josh wants to date Nicole, but she keeps shutting him down because he becomes a bumbling fool around her. Under the guidance of his roommate, he practices his moves by collecting girl’s phone numbers, but he really only cares about Nicole. However, Nicole now feels that she would just be another notch on his belt, instead of someone special.
Reactions
For the most part I enjoyed this book. I didn’t like Josh very much, despite his playboy ways being an act. He liked Nicole, but that didn’t stop him from flirting with every girl that looked his way. But girls will appreciate how foolish he gets when he talks to Nicole. My favorite parts were Nicole’s fantasy world where Ellon had to go on the quest. Nicole’s unhappiness due to loneliness and not pursuing her dreams was infinitely relatable.
The Giver [Lois Lowry]

Lois Lowry. The Giver
Houghton Mifflin Company, 1993
YA. Fantasy. Newbery
Summary
The Giver is about a society of the future, where it is slowly revealed that humanity has created a perfect world. It is a world without strife, hunger, fear, pain, or injustice. People are open about their thoughts and feelings. Families are chosen units and people’s life choices are mapped out for them. Jonas was born into this world and it is the only way he knows.
When children reach the age of 12 they are given their “life assignments” or jobs and they begin training. Jonas is given a very special job. He is chosen to hold the memories of the past. Jonas learns about good things that his world no longer has, like snow, sunshine, and love. But he also learns about the horrible things that were eliminated for a reason, hunger, war, and pain. Jonas and his teacher, the Giver, are the only people burdened with this information. They both feel that the society is missing something- free will. People don’t know what they are missing in order to make their own choices or form their own opinions.
Reaction
I loved the book up until the very ending, I couldn’t put it down. I was left with a sense of uneasiness and doubt since the book doesn’t give you a conclusive ending. You are left wondering what happens to Jonas.
But Lowry builds an intriguing world based around the question, “are we better off with or without free will?” Humans had given up many beautiful and wonderful things, like color and sunshine, but they no longer had to deal with hunger and pain. Is that a better world? Or will people only be happy when they are free to make their own choices? Is the happiness they feel true happiness if they have nothing bad to compare the good to?
This is a book that will make teens think and ponder interesting questions using an unthreatening, imaginary world. It’s a book that leaves you with questions, not answers.
Sunday, March 21, 2010
American Born Chinese [Gene Luen Yang]

Yang, Luen Gene. American Born Chinese.
First Second Books, 2006.
YA. Graphic Novel. Fantasy. Printz.
One bright and starry night, the gods, the goddesses, the demons, and the spirits gather in heaven for a dinner party.
Summary
Three separate stories are woven together in this graphic novel. Il Jin is a Chinese American boy who is unpopular. He makes his first friend, Wei-Chen, when they bond of transformer toys. As they grow Il Jin desire to be popular grows, especially when he starts to have feelings for a pretty girl.
The second story is the Chinese fable of the Monkey King who wants to be accepted among the gods. Despite how powerful he is the gods turn him away because he is a monkey. The Monkey King grows and angry and does everything in his power to become human like.
The third story is about Danny, an all-American high school male, interested in girls and sports, except that every year his Chinese cousin comes to visit and torments Danny with his foolish and embarrassing ways.
Reaction
The three stories eventually come together in a surprise twist ending- which let me tell you- was awesome. I loved the interconnectedness of all the stories. It's a story about accepting yourself as you are, a coming of age story told in pictures. There's a reason this book as won all sorts of awards.
Airborn [Kenneth Oppel]

Oppel, Kenneth. Airborn.
New York: Eos, Harper Collins Publishers. 2004. 355 pgs.
Printz Honor. YA. Fantasy.
Sailing toward dawn, and I was perched atop the crow's nest, being the ships eyes.
Matt Cruse is the cabin boy aboard the Aurora and his deepest desire is to become a captain someday. He loves being in the air and scrambles around the ship with little fear. Because of his small build he is sent to rescue a man in a sinking hot air balloon. Matt listens to the dying man rant about mysterious creatures he has observed.
One year later Matt loses a promotion to the rich son of the ship’s owner. On the same voyage he meets the rambunctious granddaughter of the man who witnessed the mysterious creatures. It doesn’t take long for a friendship to strike up between the Matt and Kate. Unfortunately, the Aurora is soon boarded by pirates who loot the ship and don’t hesitate to kill. The pirates’ parting gift is to rip the hydrium tanks holding the Aurora aloft and leave her to sink to their deaths. The ship crash lands on the beach of a tropical, deserted island.
The two teens explore the island and discover evidence of the mysterious creatures. But what good is evidence when they are stranded on an island in the middle of the Pacificus Ocean? And what happens when Kate and Matt discover the island isn’t as deserted as they thought?
A fast paced adventure where something interesting is always happening. The themes in the story were not pressed hard but skillfully interwoven into the action oriented plot. Kate and Matt both struggled with the difficulties of their stations, one being a girl and the other being poor. Matt also touches on the subject of his father’s death. There is also the slightest touch of romance. Teens, especially males, will be drawn to the adventure of the story.
Friday, March 19, 2010
Hope Was Here [Joan Bauer]

Bauer, Joan. Hope Was Here
New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 2000. 186 pgs.
Summary
Hope’s name wasn’t always Hope. Her mother named her Tulip. Her mother also left her to be raised by her aunt, Addie. Hope has spent the first sixteen years of her life roaming around the United States with Addie working in different diners. Hope knows how difficult life can be and how important it is to have hope, that’s why she changed her name.
Now she has to leave New York City and head out to Mulhoney, Wisconsin where Addie takes over running the diner of a man diagnosed with leukemia. This man, G.T., may be dying but he decides to run for mayor against the most corrupt politician in the state, Millstone. The teens in the town take up the campaign, fighting for a better future. They are led by a core group of students including Hope and the diner’s grill man, Braverman. G. T. runs for mayor on a platform of honesty, he won’t stoop to the dirty politics that his opponent uses. The opposition uses intimidation tactics, beats up Braverman, attempts to get the diner shut down, and finally downright lies about G. T.’s health.
Meanwhile, Hope is also dealing with her own personal issues. She dreams about her dad coming to find her. She starts to have feelings for Braverman despite her rule against dating co-workers. Hope worries about G. T.’s health. Then her aunt starts to date G. T. and Braverman asks her on date. Now she’s worrying about her aunt falling in love with a dying man and Braverman won’t talk to her after she walked away from his request.
ReactionsThis book kept me interested. It was a book that reminded me there are good and honorable people in the world and sometimes they get to win. Teens will love the idea that they can stand up for a cause and be heard. It received a Newbery Honor and was obviously well written. Hope is the ideal that we hold onto when life gets tough and she was able to live up to her name.
Thursday, March 5, 2009
Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist

Teen: Realistic Fiction
First line: The day begins in the middle of the night. I am not paying attention to anything but the bass in my hand, the noise in my ears.
Nick and Norah meet in a chance encounter and spend the entire night flitting back and forth between love and hate. Both are influenced from recent experiences of bad relationships and must learn to let go and trust each other.
I liked this book a lot, which is surprising considering I am not into the whole indie/punk/rock scene. I’m not even sure that’s the correct thing to call it. I don’t mind gay references and the girl on girl action in the bathroom was kinda hot, but the amount of cussing was a real turnoff for me. I don’t appreciate books that use fuck ten times on the same page. But the love story was good, and the teen angst was believable.
Favorite Quotes:
"When the rain falls you just let it fall and you grin like a mad man and you dance with it, because if you can make yourself happy in the rain then you’re doing pretty alright in life."
"I feel like I could drown in this, in him. I have fallen into the darkness, not the darkness of the deranged or the depressed, but the darkness of the consumed, where all I see, hear, taste, feel, is the probe of our mouths and hands, the warmth of our bodies pressed against each other, the urgency of his wanting, my wanting. It’s like nothing else exists in the world right now except him, me, touching, exploring, longing, needing, sharing, having."
Here Lies Arthur
Here Lies Arthur by Philip Reeves2007. Scholastic Press. 333 pgs.
Teen: Arthurian
First line: Even the woods are burning.
Myrddrin takes Gwynna in after Arthur burns down her master’s home. Gwynna plays the lady of the lake and gives Arthur his sword. She is turned into a boy and lives with Myrddrin for the next few years. Gwynna's adventures as a young boy and then a young girl are chronicled. She alone knows all the different truths and secrets about people. A reimagining of Arthurian legends where the real Arthur is a brutish warlord and the Arthur of legend is only in the stories spun by Myrddrin.
I have mixed feelings about this book. There were many elements that I liked and many I disliked. As a rule, I’m a big fan of Arthurian literature. (although I have yet to read Morte d’Arthur- it’s on my list!) But parts of it, particularly at the beginning, were difficult to read and understand. Gwynna obviously struggles with her identity- is she a boy? Is she a girl? Which one does she want to be? Life is difficult for her as a girl. The boys don’t notice her because she isn’t pretty, but she’s unsure that she wants to be noticed because she knew how they really viewed girls, and it wasn’t polite!
Gwynna also struggles with abandonment and the belief that no one loves her, not even Myrddrin. He becomes indirectly responsible for sending her towards an assured death and his health rapidly declines.
The love story between Gwynna and Peredur was pathetically weak. I’m a girl who loves a little romance and there wasn’t any at all in this book. He ignores her for the entire book and then all of a sudden in two pages they are kissing and going away together.
The best part of the book was its exploration into the power of storytelling. There were no magical elements in this novel, only tricks and deception woven by a master storyteller.
Favorite Quotes:
"Gwenhwyfar wants only him. She’s chosen him. She watches him so intently when they are together. She takes him so seriously.
And isn’t’ that what all boys want and all men, too? Just to be taken seriously?"
