Showing posts with label philip reeve. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philip reeve. Show all posts

Thursday, March 5, 2009

Here Lies Arthur

Here Lies Arthur by Philip Reeves
2007. Scholastic Press. 333 pgs.


Teen: Arthurian

First line: Even the woods are burning.

Myrddrin takes Gwynna in after Arthur burns down her master’s home. Gwynna plays the lady of the lake and gives Arthur his sword. She is turned into a boy and lives with Myrddrin for the next few years. Gwynna's adventures as a young boy and then a young girl are chronicled. She alone knows all the different truths and secrets about people. A reimagining of Arthurian legends where the real Arthur is a brutish warlord and the Arthur of legend is only in the stories spun by Myrddrin.

I have mixed feelings about this book. There were many elements that I liked and many I disliked. As a rule, I’m a big fan of Arthurian literature. (although I have yet to read Morte d’Arthur- it’s on my list!) But parts of it, particularly at the beginning, were difficult to read and understand. Gwynna obviously struggles with her identity- is she a boy? Is she a girl? Which one does she want to be? Life is difficult for her as a girl. The boys don’t notice her because she isn’t pretty, but she’s unsure that she wants to be noticed because she knew how they really viewed girls, and it wasn’t polite!

Gwynna also struggles with abandonment and the belief that no one loves her, not even Myrddrin. He becomes indirectly responsible for sending her towards an assured death and his health rapidly declines.

The love story between Gwynna and Peredur was pathetically weak. I’m a girl who loves a little romance and there wasn’t any at all in this book. He ignores her for the entire book and then all of a sudden in two pages they are kissing and going away together.

The best part of the book was its exploration into the power of storytelling. There were no magical elements in this novel, only tricks and deception woven by a master storyteller.

Favorite Quotes:


"Gwenhwyfar wants only him. She’s chosen him. She watches him so intently when they are together. She takes him so seriously.
And isn’t’ that what all boys want and all men, too? Just to be taken seriously?"